Which mace is better for Gfist sura?

let's get some math done here

Assuming both upgrade at 12 and you have 120 str

Carga = 175 Base Atk lvl 3, Variance = 26 (plus or minus), Str bonus = 175 x 120/200 = 105, refine bonus = 60+(0~35) = 60~95

Golden Mace = 110 Atk lvl 4, Variance = 22 (plus or minus), str bonus = 110 x 120/200 = 66, refine bonus = 84 +(0~112) = 84~196

Weapon Attack for Carga:

High end damage: 175+26+105+95 = 401

Low end damage: 175-26+105+60 = 314

Weapon Attack for Golden Mace:

High end damage: 110+22+66+196 = 394

Low end damage: 110-22+66+84 = 238

Now we know that Golden have a equip attack add on, so the final attack range before any cards should be:

394 + 39 = 433

238 + 39 = 277

Since they both have same card, so it doesn't matter the final result.

As you can see the Carga have average = 357, while Golden Mace have average = 355

By seeing the average number, they both yield the same

By seeing the high end, golden mace win

By seeing the low end, Carag win

So unless you are extreme lucky that you can pull out high end damage every time you fist, Carga is you choice.

So we have a though that they both yield the same, let's see the cost to make the weapon:

Carga = only need to +12 (The lowest cost of it would be 10 ori and 2 badium, and the upgrade fee for lvl 3 weapon)

Golden Mace = a Slot Ad to slot it, then get FS 5/6, then +12 (the lowest cost, 1 Seagod, 1 A class coin, 10 ori and 2 badium and the upgrade fee for lvl 4 weapon)

I'm sure Golden Mace takes more effort AND zeny to make then the carga.

Golden Mace VS Carga

Hard to make VS easy to make while the damage wise is kinda same.

so, go for Carga

Edited by bassman767, 20 June 2014 - 10:03 PM.

#1 Hakobune

#2 Baturiano

#3 bassman767

#4 Datrax

#5 ems422

0 user(s) are reading this topic