3 replies to this topic

[Hissis]

Ok,my question is... What is better for GFIST?

 

My ATK without RWC Ring FS 3/2 (gold scaraba)/D.ring is : 501 (without STR +20 too)

 

Total SP using INT +20  is : 4500.

 

So,+41 ATK from RWC ring or +100 SP ?

 

i guess SP is better but idk exactly ,thanks for answers

[ka10]

i'm guessing that 501 ATK is just the sum from the numbers on your character window, since this is actually quite low as a "real" total ATK;

a +100 SP gear would slightly give more that just that since it gets modified by %SP gears;

 

so there's no way to know exactly w/out more info; in can be one or the other depending on the actual setup;

a rough idea is that ATK contributes more damage on the lower end of ATK+SP ← this essentially translates into "how good can you get the total setup to be", while as you increase this ATK+SP limit, SP tries to catch up in terms of damage contribution (but never catches up to ATK, but can get close to it);

players rely on SP gear rather heavily since it's usually easier to increase SP by a large amount than to increase ATK by a comparable amount that would produce equal results damage-wise;

 

factors that matter would be, base level, total of all stats, total of all %damage modifiers (ATK, racial, etc), total of all equip and weapon ATK, total of all +SP and %SP modifiers, etc

 

do you have the RWC ring w/ card and enchants already? if so, you could just try to borrow a d.ring from a friend/guildie to compare - easiest way to go

otherwise, you can do calculations on your own to get the real total ATK and mSP and just plug in to the gfist formula:  ATK*[ 8 + (maxSP/10) ]

[ka10]

for a rough answer, if you have great %damage mods (especially if it's more/much more than your %SP mods), go with the RWC ring;

sorry too busy to setup arbitrary calculations, i'm sure the irowiki calc can give a roughly ok approximation for gear comparisons

Edited by ka10, 15 June 2015 - 06:54 PM.

[Hissis]

Really thanks for the answer dude,im using +12 B.Claw and maybe the ATK can be better...

 

i did some tests but they're not accurate since i was using a Glove of sura(+5 STR,and gives +175 SP for me),then i tested using RWC Ring without gold scaraba card,just the FS 3/2 (21ATK),the damage difference on a Poring (yeah,i should test on pvp but is more easy to find porings than a ''punch bag'').

 

The damage difference was 10k (9.5k exaclty),but glove of sure gives +75 SP than diabolous ring and +5 STR...

 

Reading ur answer... probably RWC Ring would be better for PVP aspect and Diabolous ring for PVM aspect.

 

Anyways,ty