11 replies to this topic

[Loki01376]

I think im missing something here but it doesn't hurt to ask for gfist i know the Carga has the best attack along with 2 cards slots but with the malangdo enchants wouldn't the Erde be better if you put 2 fighting spirit 7 on it. The Erde would have 3 more attack than the carga plus the extra 50 sp the weapon gives so wouldnt it be better in turns of Gfist damage?

[Qani]

Correct me if I'm wrong, but FS doesn't go into weapon atk calculation, but only equipment attack. Making it less ideal. So maybe that's why.

[Baturiano]

If youre fisting boss monsters I would go with the card slots. 3 atk and 50 sp isnt going to beat 40% more damage to boss

[Loki01376]

Erde has 2 card slots same as the carga

[KmXSrd]

bcuz the carga icon looks better obvs

[kasshin]

FS enchanted golden mace [2] might be a good choice too due to it being a level 4 weapon, but it does have lower weapon atk like Erde. I know someone was selling double FS golden mace a while ago so maybe someone's tested it before.

[Baturiano]

Ah I see I thought the FS enchants override the slots.

[Riakuta]

FS enchanted golden mace [2] might be a good choice too due to it being a level 4 weapon, but it does have lower weapon atk like Erde. I know someone was selling double FS golden mace a while ago so maybe someone's tested it before.

+12 Double Liberation Golden Mace Fighting Spirit 7 Fighting Spirit 7 > +12 Double Liberation Carga Mace
+12 Double Liberation Golden Mace Fighting Spirit 7 Fighting Spirit 6 > +12 Double Liberation Carga Mace
+12 Double Liberation Golden Mace Fighting Spirit 6 Fighting Spirit 6 = +12 Double Liberation Carga Mace

The cost of getting double Fighting Spirit 7s is definitely not worth the amount of damage increased using Golden Mace over Carga Mace.

If you do manage to get double Fighting Spirit 7 Enchants Erde [2] would be the better option for those enchants considering lower variable damage and increase to max damage by 12.5 x ATK.

Edited by Riakuta, 27 March 2013 - 06:16 AM.

[Qani]

Purely ATK speaking, FS 14 Erde wouldn't beat Carga mace or even come that close, but I guess 50 sp can make a difference.

[Riakuta]

Purely ATK speaking, FS 14 Erde wouldn't beat Carga mace or even come that close, but I guess 50 sp can make a difference.

Erde Fighting Spirit 7 Fighting Spirit 7 = 178 Weapon Atk
Carga Mace = 175 Weapon Atk

Edited by Riakuta, 27 March 2013 - 09:40 AM.

[Qani]

FS is equipment ATK..
Base Weaon ATK > Equip ATK

[Havenn]

is a +12 RWC Memory Mace [AK] better than a 2x AK +12 Carga Mace for G-fist?