You know there's only 3 guilds who have taken the castle and the only time any guild has gotten recognition was for winning the very first WoE. You didn't hear WP screaming for joy every time we (Collision) took/kept the castle.
Because the three WoE winners were Collision, Ice (allied with Collision for the first half, which is when they won), and Aesir (allied with Collision for the second half, which is when they won), it probably isn't considered very impressive that Aesir (one of the top three in WoE on the basis of having taken the Emp already) still has the emp. Its all happened before. Technically, anyone else would have made it something worth noticing. As is, it's still shows we're holding the status quo.
That's at the official level of course. Obviously privately Aesir's ally will be congratulating them in their execution of siege, but from a public level it's technically not quite as impressive pulling off what they have been for a while now.
So on that note, the public words being traded around to directly or indirectly bash around either guilds or "other guilds" probably isn't a good idea here. Just send a private message to someone in Aesir with a congratulations... or just move on and plan for thursday (or move on in general for those who aren't in WoE). This public stuff isn't necessary, especially the hateful arguments.