That said, it should be obvious it would take an awful lot of fungineering to come from kRO to even make blacksmithing worthwhile again, so why even bother caring about the ranking list these days-- whether you're complaining there is no point in resetting it --- or complaining its being reset at all. It should be a fine print nobody cares about.
Dear Oda,
I would like to reply to this quote and together, appeal against blacksmith resetting. Please listen to a player voice, however unimportant he/she is.
First let me explain why "I" care about blacksmith rank resetting.
I'm one of the few active forging smiths in this server, in "few" I mean 4-5... Only 3 out of 10 ranked BS are actually selling their VVS, I'm one of them.
BS ranking is really worthless for most people, but for those on the list, especially me, it means a lot.... Friends used to ask me why I forge, and I just tell them "I love forging, I'm a blacksmith". I'm a blacksmith since I've first played RO some 11-12 years ago. Since then I'm on and off RO and been on several server, both official and privates, like many other people. I just returned to iRO when it went on steam on November, 2013. All those times my main char always be a forging smith.
I started from scratch again since my old ID has only a lv 10 novice with nothing left in kafra. I made new friends, grind, vend, buildup my own resources, and after 6 months I was ready to be a ranked blacksmith again.
Forging has changed a lot during these years, but something never change. I still love to forge very very strong elemental weapons. I love to hear the sound effect when I successfully created one, and I laugh & /swt & awww with my friends when it broke (more often than not). I love to see the points adding up 10 by painfully 10 points for each weapon I created and know that I'm another step closer to the top ranking. VVS weapons are still have a tiny niche in the market, a few players are still using them nowadays. I love making decent weapons for my friends and guild mates. I forge for free for newbies with too low budget to buy good weapons or elemental converters. I teach new players how to get free gears from eden equipment quest, and if they still insist they need my VVS, I'll sell to them at super uber extra special discounted rate. I buy back my VVS when my customers don't need them anymore and offer to exchange the weapon to another element if they don't have enough zeny to buy a new one. Once in a while I'll type /blacksmith and think "Ah! look at my points! It's still xxxx behind the no.1, but wow... I've made so many weapons!" ... and I'm happy.
Forging is very different from brewing. Pots are consumable, you used the ranked pots, they're gone. So the reset won't effect much, there're so many brewers and the alchemist points are enormous anyway. VVS is another matter, they last, you buy one at certain price, sometimes a bit higher because it's raked, then you have it for... how ever long you will have it. Some people who use VVS has tight budget but they have the right to get what they paid, if then paid for ranked VVS, no matter how puny the bonus is... they should get a ranked weapon. No matter if the forger is still playing or already quit, if he/she had once tried hard enough to be on the rank, they should have the reward for their hardship, and their weapons should be ranked for as long as someone topped them. Their points shouldn't got wiped by some reset with no reason.
I once saw someone said the reset is to make chance for a new player to get on the rank, but for blacksmith rank, it isn't impossible to be on the rank. The hardest part is to be on the TOP, and if someone want to be the top blacksmith in this server, like me, that person should try hard. It took me a few months of forging to reach the 10th rank, and right now after a year and one reset I'm still fighting my way up to the top, unsuccessfully still... since the no.1 is so damn good. It's fun competing the fellow forgers and fighting to keep the position, every time I'm closer to the first ranking, he'll just whack something and gain a few thousand points and I'm falling so far behind again, still, it's fun in trying so.... but no fun at all if the points keep resetting ever few months. It's even more difficult for new players who wants to be on the rank (if ever), because to gain points are very hard and need a lot of resources, each reset will set them back to the beginning again with all their effort gone... their zeny lost, for nothing.
If nothing, I'm still thinking that if BS rank resetting benefit no one while it's a huge lost for a few players, then you shouldn't reset it at all.
Again, please understand.
Edited by Chocola, 10 March 2015 - 08:02 PM.