No one would buy cash shop items if in game items which anybody with excessive leisure can farm are more powerful. Game would of become bot to win instead and the company will not generate any revenues. Using cash shop items also shows love, loyalty, and support to the game.
Wrong. It's a matter of balancing the rewards. Cash shop has been providing decent items for a long time already, and very few of them were really OP. And even the most OP of them (HWHB?) was not even close to what has been released recently. Also, most of the highest rewarding things you can do in the game cannot be done by bots... probably.
half correct friend. oh its p2w, but not 100%. not yet.
newer players with no connections need p2w because they realize the difficulty in attaining zeny/gears from nothing. this helps RO generate revenue and stay alive amidst competition from newer games.
older players dont need to use real money because they have the knowledge of conversions and how to apply them, which involves game-related zenymaking tactics that don't utilize p2w to make zeny, yet reap p2w benefits. in example, a person can use their zeny making tactics in game to sustain VIP without using real money, or they can acquire so much zeny that they exchange it for WPE to buy boxes or KP. once you have the knowledge of how to make zeny (and there are many, many ways), you can cross over the boundary of in-game currency to WPE/KP rewards to avoid spending real money entirely.
Up to this point I totally agree with you. Also, with Sewasan's posts. The only thing that bothers me is that the gap between what you can get in game and what you can get by cash shop was ok, but has been consistently and overwhelmingly increasing. Maybe we already got to an alarming point, and if it keeps going on, playing wil be less and less rewarding, and most players will see no reason to keep playing. I know that many has already quit because of it. If only they worked towards keeping WoE alive...