It's not so much of a single player carrying a guild, but if you played pre-renewal, you know what I mean about a single player being an impact player. As in, they had the gear/skill necessary to wipe entire guilds by themselves or how guilds won or lost based on if that player was there. Everyone knew who Writhing was back in the day, if you seen him, it was like "Oh 
.." cause you knew what would happen next. Back then people had things (Valk Armors/Valk Shields, CK, etc) that made you epic, I just miss the feeling of the exclusivity with things. Like I remember seeing Courage with the first +9 Diabolus armor, I thought "Damn I want that one day". Now, be it vet or noob, everyone has the same and there's nothing that sets people apart anymore. Renewal, you can do everything. You can have the damage to one shot, dps to drop people in seconds AND tank everyone. It's no longer about anything other than who has the most pots (I do have a lot, so I'm not complaining there lol), people in guild and the most OP classes.
If one player made that much of a difference, doesn't that mean there were groups of players that made no difference. Why would anyone want to play where one person wipes out an entire guild. That doesn't sound like balance or fun to me. It kinda of sounds like what's the point?
trans classes stop at 99/50 I believe. That means people spend even less time leveling, and there is much less end game content and maps. On this hypothetical server people would only really stick around for WoE and don't play the rest of the time. And you couldn't make it void of Kafrashop because then the server would be even less financially viable. I just feel there is a minority of players who want a pre-renewal server, and it just seems like a lot because those people are the ones who are staples of the forums.
I do wholeheartedly agree that the 150 level cap is too high and ruins the game. It's just stupid a character can have 100 in every stat, that's part of balance issues.
I would like to partake in a WoE where everyone had to start fresh, and there was no kafra shop influence so people had to upgrade the old fashion way, and didn't have kafra items. And the classes were balanced trans classes. One of the big problems in RO is new players can't even access WoE because established players have done WoE for years, they have the zenny, gear, upgrades, and gathered those from years of playing. The main difference should be skill.
Here's what you do. Start a petition for a non 3rd class WoE. You have to prove to GMs that people agree with your idea. I seriously doubt that a new server is a good idea by any stretch of the imagination, considering the server populations are cascading downhill.
iRO Server Populations over timeIf you can get enough people signing the petition, convince GMs that this new WoE will draw old players back to the game. I mean WoE is RO's big draw, and if you can please the people now who are well established in 3rd class WoE by leaving their WoE alone, while giving players who feel forgotten a place to return to by establishing a trans WoE, I think this might just be crazy enough to work.
