Posted 17 December 2014 - 07:51 AM
Honestly, I did my judgments in a hurry and didn't have time to see which entries belonged to whom. So I apologize if my reasoning aren't detailed.
#1
Creativity/Concept: 3 - Overused.
Appeal: 4 - Easy to read and eye-catching.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#2
Creativity/Concept: 4 - Not an NPC you'd expect on a wanted poster.
Appeal: 3 - Too uninspired; text is hard to read.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#3
Creativity/Concept: 3 - Feels cliché.
Appeal: 3 - Not well-done; a bit Engrishy with random capitalizations.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#4
Creativity/Concept: 4 - Interesting choice.
Appeal: 4 - Creative.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#5
Creativity/Concept:5 - Definitely outside the box.
Appeal: 1 - Feels somewhat vicious for the target in question.
Technical: 2 - Doesn't count as in-game lore and it sort of violates Rule #5 since it talks about other people even though CMs are allowed (which is kinda contradicting).
#6
Creativity/Concept: 3 - Feels cliché.
Appeal: 3 - Text has odd grammar and the format is awkward.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#7
Creativity/Concept: 5 - Interesting and unexpected.
Appeal: 5 - Witty and creative.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#8
Creativity/Concept: 4 - Interesting choice.
Appeal: 2 - Wall of text in a font that is amazingly hard to read.
Technical: 2 - MUCH too long to read.
#9
Creativity/Concept: 4 - Cute choice.
Appeal: 4 - Short and simple, but doesn't use proper sentence structure.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#10
Creativity/Concept: 5 - Definitely outside the box.
Appeal: 3 - Although creative, the text is too small and clumped together.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#11
Creativity/Concept: 4 - Interesting choice.
Appeal: 4 - Text is easy to read and creative.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#12
Creativity/Concept: 4 - Almost cliché but not quite there yet.
Appeal: 4 - Creative text that's easy to read.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#13
Creativity/Concept: 5 - Good choice.
Appeal: 4 - Creative and witty.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#14
Creativity/Concept: 5 - Good choice.
Appeal: 4 - A little lengthy, but creatively written.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#15
Creativity/Concept: 4 - Interesting choice.
Appeal: 3 - Engrishy and breaks the 4th wall.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#16
Creativity/Concept: 1 - Not even a wanted poster.
Appeal: 2 - Too many different fonts used.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#17
Creativity/Concept: 5 - Definitely outside the box.
Appeal: 4 - Pretty creative and witty. Amusing.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#18
Creativity/Concept: 4 - Crossover with another game, but creative nonetheless.
Appeal: 3 - Text is pretty hard to read, but witty.
Technical: 4 - Follows contests rules and half-related to RO.
#19
Creativity/Concept: 4 - Decent choice.
Appeal: 5 - Text has spelling errors and uses shorthand words. Breaks the 4th wall.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#20
Creativity/Concept: 5 - Good choice.
Appeal: 5 - Good concept and good readability.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#21
Creativity/Concept: 5 - Good choice.
Appeal: 4 - Odd grammar and breaks the 4th wall, but still creative.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#22
Creativity/Concept: 4 - Interesting choice.
Appeal: 3 - Odd grammar and breaks the 4th wall.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#23
Creativity/Concept: 5 - Good choice.
Appeal: 5 - Creative (if not a little disturbing).
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#24
Creativity/Concept: 5 - Definitely out of the box.
Appeal: 5 - Pretty creative for the subject in question.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#25
Creativity/Concept: 3 - Interesting choice, but getting cliché.
Appeal: 2 - Sounds like a rant and breaks the 4th wall.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#26
Creativity/Concept: 4 - Random.
Appeal: 2 - Too vague, doesn't even mention the target.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#27
Creativity/Concept: 3 - Interesting choice, but getting cliché.
Appeal: 3 - Not much creativity.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#28
Creativity/Concept: 5 - Good choice.
Appeal: 4 - Odd format, but readable.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#29
Creativity/Concept: 4 - Interesting choice.
Appeal: 1 - Too much text going on, no discernible flow.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#30
Creativity/Concept: 5 - Good choice.
Appeal: 5 - Short and simple; creative.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#31
Creativity/Concept: 3 - Interesting choice, but not really a wanted poster.
Appeal: 3 - Too many different fonts used, hard to read.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#32
Creativity/Concept: 3 - Kind of cliché.
Appeal: 3 - Cursing and weird text flow.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#33
Creativity/Concept: 5 - Good choice.
Appeal: 4 - Creative, but odd grammar at the end.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#34
Creativity/Concept: 5 - Good choice.
Appeal: 3 - Lengthy and not very creative.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.
#35
Creativity/Concept: 3- Kind of cliché.
Appeal: 3 - Somewhat creative.
Technical: 5 - Follows contests rules and related to RO.