Well , i believe to get a good class balance , they need have to follow good pattern to all classes .
Here a list of skill suggestions to be analyzed and discuss .
Physical classes – high defense /low magic resistance
Physical class auto attack (assassin ,berserker , ranger , protector )
Classes based with high speed auto attack , defense debuffs , stun and slow (defense/offense buffs)
· Protector / Defender
Rush and Chain of Restraint- (commander skill tree) move to defender skill tree
Quick Attack - increase attack speed and hostility each auto attack hit
Remove low Blow -(if quick attack increase hostility each hit i think this is useless)
Heals based in a % of total HP (no more magic items in melee toons )
· Ranger/ Hunter
Bombing and High-Angle Firing - move to Hunter skill tree
Diversionary Firing and Smoke Shell Firing - move to ranger skill tree( lvl 10 50m range )
Poison Bomb Firing - reduces 30% resistance at lvl 10 instead of defense
Blessing of haste – from tempest skill Tree
· Berserk
Bear-like Stamina and Bugle of Carnage - from Warlord skill tree to Berserk skill tree
Lethal Death Blow and Megaton Slash - move to Warlord skill tree
Bartuk Legacy -move to Warlord skill tree reduces % resistance instead of defense
Reckless Attack - reduces 10% resistance at lvl10 instead of defense increase time
· Assassin / Rogue ( i never play to know what can do here )
Brutal Scud - move to rogue skill tree
Move some duals swords skills to SR (increasing Targets )
Sniping - move to rogue skill tree (will be a good Skill to aa Assassin)
Physical class SS (shadow runner, warlord ,avenger ,commander)
Classes based in area damage ,silent skills ,area stun ,and dot damage (passive defense/offense skills)
· Shadow Runner / Rogue
Sniping - move to rogue skill tree
Poison Arrow - move to Shadow Runner skill tree add max to 8 targets at lvl 10
Paralise Nerves - Slow enemies 8 targets -3m/s 20sec 1,5sec cast time
Piercing Arrow , Deadly Strike - increase targets to 8 no cast time
Instant Accel - increase skill critical chance instead accuracy
Remove Long Range Weapon Mastery and add a passive defense skill (defense up like Avengers )
Move Dual swords poison and bleed skills from Assassin skill tree increase targets
· Commander / Defender
Rush and Chain of Restraint - move to defender skill tree
Promise of Victory – increase Skill critical additional damage and critical add damage personal buff instead accuracy
· Avenger
Explosion Trap , Guided Trap , Bomb Trap, Paralysis Trap – physical damage instead light damage
Avenging Strike – range 10 – 30m with a chance of stun 1s
· Warlord
Bear-like Stamina and Bugle of Carnage – move to Berserk skill tree
Lethal Death Blow and Megaton Slash – from berserk skill tree
Bartuk Legacy – from berserk skill tree reduces % resistence instead of defense