186 replies to this topic

[MattyL904]

 

The effect will be based on dawnte and Hikari Yari's suggestions: 

 

+3 Luck

Enables use of level 1 discount 

Has a low chance to give players an orcish face temporarily when physically attacking. 

 

I misunderstood the competition I think.. I thought we were supposed to vote for the best one! Can we re vote? It seems you chose the worst idea for some reason.  

 

The way the clover is set now doesnt make sense to me.. so when I attack theres a chance that something bad will happen to me (I will get an orcish face).  Is 3 luk so good that it needs to have something as bad as getting an orcish face temporarily?  Thats not LUCKY at all.  Please rethink this horrible piece of gear that could have been very interesting and good yet instead is a piece of junk.

[Myzery]

Make sure that this person gets their name on it and can't sell it to someone else to have their name on it.

 

It's such a trash item now outside of potting.

 

Oda? More like Heimdallr.

Stop ruining things.

Edited by Myzery, 18 March 2014 - 05:32 PM.

[MattyL904]

change name "Unlucky Clover" ^^;;;

!!!!!

Or Favoritism clover.. Who would think the winner is in Valhalla..  O yeah.. just like all the Megaphone users are in Valhalla.  Hmmm seems fair to me.

[generalCOOLyo]

worst idea!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[MizunoAoi]

Can we at least know how you went about picking the abilities?  So we know who to blame?

[Panteperu]

Well, that was totally unexpected. Let's hope you can reconsider this decision

[Exhale]

!!!!!

Or Favoritism clover.. Who would think the winner is in Valhalla..  O yeah.. just like all the Megaphone users are in Valhalla.  Hmmm seems fair to me.

 

There is 2 megaphone users in vh and 2 in other guilds.. Let's not distract from the point that this is an awful item effect.

[Exhale]

Totally forgot there are even more Megaphones users, glad you posted ^^

[MattyL904]

Im not saying people shouldnt be allowed to win because of a guild.. I'm saying a guild that "May" be favored won the competition with probably the worst idea..  Its an item that should give a positive effect and it has a NEGATIVE one and that person won the contest.  I dont quite understand that.

 

Who is Dante? Why was he brought up?

 

Also that list of players that have megaphones is high inaccurate.  Im 100% sure myzery doesn't have megaphone privileges but this isn't what the topic is about so I will stay on track.

 

Please just have a poll for a few days and whoever has the most votes wins.  Thats 120% fair.

Edited by MattyL904, 18 March 2014 - 06:11 PM.

[Bucetation]

Well...

Its at least it gives 3 on luck...

Orc Head needs to be reconsidered cause it bugs all the helmets...

 

Discount on lvl 1 doesn't mean nothing at all... soo it is just an item with 3 on luck.

Try +3 on Luck
25% more heal from Potatoes
Little chance to drop potato.

Its a little more Irish.

[Fables]

lol the gms troll. chill out and stop being so paranoid about who wins what.

[MizunoAoi]

I don't care who wins.

 

I just think the choices picked are not very clover-like, lucky, or just plain wtf.

 

Seriously, discount 1 is outclassed by a card and the fact anyone who's anyone has a vend-slave anyway with OC and DC 10.

And orc face...  there are no words.

[jenkat]

I was one of those who seconded the orc face idea, because even though it's hideous, it's also hilarious. Ain't nobody got time to hate me too?
I agree that this sounds like an April Fool's joke, so maybe you are being trolled. If not, then blame me while I wear one.

 

 

[addendum: I hadn't actually given thought to the buggy way it interacts with headgear, and considering that aspect of the issue, it's not hilarious, it is aggravating; so on that part, I am repentant, and agree with others here]

Edited by jenkat, 18 March 2014 - 07:24 PM.

[zerowon]

Glad I sold mine before I went on vacation

[Rythen]

Looks like the only use mine has is to be cute in town.

 

Luk+3 isn't worth it in PvM anyway, and this effect only makes it more useless.

[dawnte]

oh ? i won? 

 

wow so many haters lel

 

i don't even play classic but what the hell, 

 

Oda, my ign on classic is Erin

 

Thanks for picking my suggestion

 

And thanks sarah (ceinchase) for notifying me about my victory ahue

[AllyBB]

Omg, those effects are awful! No one is going to use discount 1, people are never going to wear this in pvm because of the orc face, and one of the winners doesn't play classic. At least it's not game breaking though. >_<

 

 

[MizunoAoi]

I kind of feel sorry for you, dawnte, posting your ign like that...

 

Just remember to use /ex name if people harass you.

[dawnte]

lol, why thank you 

 

i dont mind though :'D 

[kschamp]

It's good, I like this.  Doesn't make it OP like people are asking for.  Would have been cool if it added +2-3 Crit but all is well

[Xellie]

!!!!!

Or Favoritism clover.. Who would think the winner is in Valhalla..  O yeah.. just like all the Megaphone users are in Valhalla.  Hmmm seems fair to me.

 

 

Lol and you think posting something like this is a good idea because? You better be high or something. I'm sure that if more people cared about the game and played it as much as the people in Valhalla, or those from the south pront guild do, there would be more megaphone users.

 

Nice to know who has been bitching behind our backs now tho. I had heard rumors.

 

ANYWAY

 

Adding crit % is a horrble idea. And the reason I say that is that I have a crit sinx and you can already stack enormous amounts of crit modifiers (she's only 92 so don't pull the god item card). and do huge and fast damage. I think.... those classes are good enough.

 

[squirreI]

Useless and boring headgear aside from potting. I want to see at least 4 more pages of negative feedback.

[jenkat]

I'd like to see people with a healthy sense of humor.

[MattyL904]

oh ? i won? 

 

wow so many haters lel

 

i don't even play classic but what the hell, 

 

Oda, my ign on classic is Erin

 

Thanks for picking my suggestion

 

And thanks sarah (ceinchase) for notifying me about my victory ahue

Even worse.. Someone who doesn't even play the server won...  Funny stuff. 

 

*GMs at the Office*

"How can we piss of the community again?" 

"Oh yes I got it, lets waste a "headgear slot" on something that has an UNLUCKY effect and the winner wont even play the Classic server."

"Yes, That will really piss them off!!"

 

 

You really have outdone yourselves this time.  I must applaud you and you definitely deserve a pat on the back!

[MattyL904]

Lol and you think posting something like this is a good idea because? You better be high or something. I'm sure that if more people cared about the game and played it as much as the people in Valhalla, or those from the south pront guild do, there would be more megaphone users.

 

Nice to know who has been bitching behind our backs now tho. I had heard rumors.

 

ANYWAY

 

Adding crit % is a horrble idea. And the reason I say that is that I have a crit sinx and you can already stack enormous amounts of crit modifiers (she's only 92 so don't pull the god item card). and do huge and fast damage. I think.... those classes are good enough.

 

 

So because I say something in front of the entire community means I have been doing it behind your back..? Wheres the logic. LAWL!